I was diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome 2 years ago. This has offered me insight and explanation as to why I often operate differently to (seemingly) everyone else in the known world.
I have a Masters degree in Logic (for real) and a research addiction that I really haven't ever seen in anyone else.
But I'm also painfully aware that we live in a society obsessed with pathologising and labelling so I assume most people reading this will over-relate and be exclaiming that they ALSO have this obsession with logic and research. Well great for you guys.
I am in something of a misanthropic mood. This is new to me. In general, Aspies (of which I am depressingly typical) are over-empathetic. When I see a news story about a child in peril, it becomes my child and the tears of the mother become my own tears. I suffer injustices alongside those who suffer. I grieve for the dead and the dying, I ache for the lonely and the estranged and I weep and weep and weep for the persecuted. You too, right? Thought so.
The things I hate the most in the academic sense are cognitive dissonance (finding that my beliefs are incompatible with each other logically) the cognitive dissonance of others when I have already overcome it through, yknow, THINKING ABOUT SHIT (that was aggressive. See misanthropy above) and injustice. Ironically, the inner sense of 'justice' I seem to be so burdened with is difficult to rationally locate. But I have found that I can logically analyse states of affairs that I find to be unjust and locate the source of my misgivings not in some abstract principle or entity, but in the lack of inward coherence of the attempted rationalisation of actions of the persecutor. In this way I manage to avoid thinking too hard or too often about the source of morality or justice in any metaphysical sense and focus on my ABSOLUTE MORAL OUTRAGE at a situation, whilst remaining entirely logical in my thinking, instead of running away with emotional thinking like so many normies. Ugh. Normies. That's what we magical Aspies sometimes call you Neurotypical types. It's like "muggle" and just as slightly insulting. See misanthropy, above.
In these modern lives of social media, it is hard to be shielded from the MORAL OUTRAGE of pretty much everyone we know. Sometimes it is a simple outrage - someone hits a baby, baby hitting is bad. I recognise your outrage. Here is mine *clicks share*.
However, sometimes the MORAL OUTRAGE just doesn't resonate that simply with me so in order to assess whether I should click the share button, sign the petition, donate that "only £1" or attend the event, I hit the research and do a think.
Every now and again, I find that the moral outrage of the majority is actually complete bullshit. Either a massive overreaction to an almost non-existent problem (I did a blog before about rear facing car seats, don't even fucking get me started) (I can't drive and my smallest child is 4 feet tall though so whatever) or else an emotional knee-jerk reaction that seeeeeeems like it should be the right thing to be angry about but actually when you think about it makes no fucking sense and is actually pretty fucking offensive.
So here's my point.
Recently, I've been really pissed off about feminism. As a result of people seeming to not understand what feminism is and disagree with me on what we should define as "a woman", I bought some books and booked a weekend away.
I have spent 3 days now, fully (ish) focused on reading, listening, thinking and rationalising whether trans women are actually women, what femaleness essentially is, what femininity actually is, what socialism really is in the modern world, whether the arguments I've had pretty much every day for the last 3 months have been my fault.
In conclusion; fuck you. Fuck all of you.
I have read Femininity by Susan Brownmiller, The Second Sex by Simone deBeauvoir and The Female Eunuch by Germaine Greer as well as countless articles, news stories and it feels like almost all of wikipedia. I have been back to Ancient Greek texts about female and male, about slavery and freedom. I have looked at government definitions and scientific studies about gender and cognition. I have looked at the development of psychological and sociological theories of gender and I have examined my views from every conceivable angle.
And my conclusion is: Fuck You.
No one else reacts to an issue like this. I haven't at all changed my views, I've just given myself more fuel to use in arguments with idiots who cannot use reason and do not take the time to research. I don't CARE any more about the opinions of anyone incapable of rational and critical analysis and no-one cares about rationally and critically analysing their gut reactions and emotional thinking.
Turns out a lot of it comes down to this: People are fucking stupid.
Women love their slavery, women love patriarchy, women are masochistic fools on the whole who wouldn't choose to have equal rights even if they were offered to them tomorrow. Nothing will ever change because basically no one wants it to.
The big revelation is this: I don't care.
I am unaffected by women's issues because I am self-employed and self-sufficient. No one is affecting my rights and I am not affecting anyone else's. I have literally no reason to care whatsoever so from now on that is what I shall endeavour to do.
The same goes for socialism. People are fucking stupid. Most of the people in this country are getting utterly screwed over by the elite few at the top of the pile. But who votes for the Tories? The poor. They love it. They love throwing the blame at brown people and Eastern European people or at the EU in general. There's some Lord Whatnot in his 25th Bentley drinking the tears of the slaves he keeps at his 8 castles and the terrible fact is that they are tears of JOY! They bloody LOVE being slaves, being stolen from and lied to! "He probably worked really hard to be born into that inheritance!" they say. So fuck them, if they love it, what good is it to point out to them their condition!? If they wanted change they could vote for it and we just had a massive election with not only a good enough Socialist candidate, but the BEST socialist candidate we will likely ever see - and what do we do? Bitch and moan about how the brown lady he works with forgot a number one time. Well slow clap for us. Next time I'm being punched in the face I will make sure to focus my police report on the woman next to me whose bag didn't match her fucking shoes, so I probably deserved the beating in the first place.
So yes, there you go. I am clever, you are stupid. If we disagree, I am right and you are wrong because I am super special and I have thought about it more than you. But now, I won't talk to you anymore about it because all that will happen is that I will get bogged down in logic and start furiously drawing diagrams and making lists and you will become emotional and shout TERF and CIS at me. And I'll end up blogging because at least that way people can't start punching me, matching shoes or nay.
It should suck that people will read that last paragraph as arrogance, that's because I am a woman. I AM actually special, I have a very high IQ and I usually don't say that because it usually makes people call me names but fuck you. I have thought about things more than you because if I am stating an opinion that means I've done the research. If I haven't, I ask question instead. But as my counsellor said, and since this revelation at the end of my weekend of thinking has resulted in something of a change in outlook along these lines:
Your opinion of me is inconsequential. At best.
Interesting. I also have high functioning autism/aspergers, diagnosed 2016. I have also been told I have a high IQ, and have achieved various things that would support this.
ReplyDeleteSo, knowing this about you now I am even more confused as to why you are unable to engage your aspie empathy towards this issue, towards transwomen? Because the entire reason people disagree with you so passionately is that they are blessed with the ability to recognise the human cost of views like yours.
I think the days you spent looking for academic justification of your views to make you feel better, might have been a lot more constructively spent by reading first hand accounts from transfemale writers, of why it is so damaging and dehumanising to have their right to womanhood debated. Of course the materials you say you have read are important, but it is a huge mistake to solely focus on the academic side of the issue at the expense of the human side. Academicising issues to the point where the emotional and human element is muddied is a favourite trick of the Tories, btw.
The fact you ended our argument on facebook by blocking me shortly after saying "fuck you, transwomen deny my sexuality and call it a fetish", does indicate that your views are in some way 'vengeful'. But dehumanising transwomen won't right any wrongs you have suffered, it just means you are perpetrating a new wrong.
I hope one day your heart can soften, I think the anger is really clouding your judgement on this issue. I dont think you are a bad person.
Notice how you fail to provide any actual arguments to the contrary?
ReplyDeletePlease go away. You are a waste of time and energy.
And can you really claim to have examined the issues from every conceivable angle if you havent read a range of first person accounts from actual transwomen?
ReplyDeleteNo I can’t. I was going to get to that but gave up caring in advance. I know some trans men...funny how no one cares about them isn’t it? And I will happily maintain that transsexual women are women but casually self identifying as transgender because of some magical womany feeling is bullshit and I’m not wasting any more time arguing with people sucked in by this antifeminist cult. Womanhood isn’t a right, it is a biological characteristic and wanting to sexually relate to the world as someone with a vagina is the only necessary characteristic. If biology were irrelevant then trans surgery is only cosmetic and if you believe that YOU are the transphobe not me.
Deletei dont think tallying up how many trans men and trans women we both know is really very helpful.
DeleteThe only reason I am focusing on trans females is because you are focusing your bile on them specifically.
Re read your blog post because I dont see any argument there. Your argument is basically “fuck you, i read ALL the things and I am still right”
But you didnt read all the things. You didnt even bother to read a first hand account from the very group of people you claim to be so enlightened and knowledgeable about. And now youre proudly saying you dont care enough to listen to their stories?
Thats pure bigotry, mate.
My point was actually that I could soend ages articulating actual arguments but I see no point. It’s like a cult and reasoning is pointless.
DeleteI see you aren’t bothering either. I’m a sucker for a syllogism, feel free to enlighten me.
One time, I had a post on mumsnet removed because it was anti-racist. You calling me a bigot because I hate sexists is just as absurd. If being a feminist makes me a bigot then fine. But thus far I haven’t had a single person actually manage to give me a definition of “woman” that isn’t biological and also isn’t sexist.
You are coming across as irrational and over emotional. And sexist. Not to mention the ableism, homophobia and transphobia that comes from your view. So there’s that...
Ok, i will bite. What mental gymnastics have you performed to come to the conclusion that i am ableist homophobic and transphobic?
DeleteYoure denying the agency of these women, by telling them the “right” way to identify. And youre being pretty snobbish and obnoxiously elitist by insinuating your IQ and educational background give you authority to trample over the agency of other human beings because you somehow know better than them?
Honestly mate I think you need to have a serious think about where this all comes from. I think there is some unresolved trauma here, and I sympathise - but sympathy only goes so far when you are oppressing and traumatising others.
No. While you refuse to argue your position I shall refuse to argue mine.
DeleteI dont feel my position needs arguing. My position is predicated on the respect for individual autonomy and the right to self-define gender. Your position is predicated on a lack of respect for both, you might pretend to have valid academic reasons for this but its a very unconvincing smokescreen. Your position is very clearly due to whatever personal experience youve had thats led you to hate transwomen.
DeleteI don’t feel my position needs arguing. My position is predicated on sound logical reasoning and factual reality. Your position is predicated on a lack of intelligence and lack of ability to reason. You might pretend to have respect for women but this is an unconvincing smokescreen. Your position is clearly due to an inability to process information that leads you to hate lesbians, transsexuals and people suffering a medical issue.
DeleteYour “position” directly contributes to the social exclusion, gaslighting, abuse and ultimately needless deaths of transwomen. Your “position” directly contributes to high suicide and murder rates of transwomen. Your position is one of elitism, hatred and intolerance.
DeleteI am bowing out now but please do get some help for your mental health as I think you are quite ill. Id like to think youre not inherently hateful, anyway.
Well thank goodness for that.
DeleteLong story short: Your autism has nothing to do with anything and should actually help you to understand why people are so upset by your views.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletecommented in the wrong place so moved it ^^
Delete